Before I start down this path of insanity which is trying to perfectly represent every creature in a game of Dungeons & Dragons or Pathfinder I should remind myself that my buddy runs a great game of Pathfinder with whichever miniatures he has available. I don’t mind this at all, and even find that I picture the fight looking like it should instead of being bothered by incongruous miniatures.
Having said that it is now time to overthink things. I’ve run 4E before using a combination of pre-painted miniatures and round tokens. I thought it worked rather well and assuming I need to run an encounter featuring kobolds, goblins, hobgoblins or the undead I am set. It is expanding the collection that concerns me.

Where have I seen this image recently? Kobold encounter from Keep on the Shadowfell. Miniatures and battlemap from Wizards of the Coast. Counters from Fiery Dragon.
The counters you see above are from a pdf collection provided for free by Fiery Dragon. The counters were originally square but I modified them to be round then had them printed at Costco in their photo department. I go into a little more detail here. These work great and aren’t that expensive to make. I really like how they keep the heroes as the center of attention.
So, my first option would be to buy a bunch of the Fiery Dragon counter packs in PDF and do the prep. This gives me exactly the mix of counters I need for whichever encounter I desire. If I need more of something I just print them out at Costco. There are some issues with these counters that I would fix in the next back; I would include a blank spot for numbering. Currently I’ve numbered the bottom which requires a lot of checking the bottom to identify which creature has taken what damage.
If I don’t want to do the work there is also the various pre-printed counters produced by Fiery Dragon. There are two styles, the older square die-cut cardboard counters and the newer round plastic counters. The older counters are less expensive, coming in at $0.05 per counter while the newer counters are $0.31 per counter. Even though they are more expensive I am leaning towards the plastic counters, if I were to go that way. They even offer a goblin-themed set.
I would get the base set and the goblin set. Hopefully Fiery Dragon will continue to release new themed sets to allow me to bulk up my forces for specific encounters. I’d also be able to use my existing counters with the new set, which is a plus.
If I were to jump off the deep end and abandon 4E for Pathfinder I would probably start with the Beginner’s Box. This gives me some rules to start with and a bunch of tokens. The tokens are standees and wouldn’t work well with my existing counters. However Paizo is releasing a boxed set based on their Bestiary sourcebook and plan sets for their published Adventure Paths. In the middle, price-wise, this option would be the one I’d chose if I was switching to Pathfinder.
I still haven’t decided which way I’d like to go. I have plenty of time though. The group that wants me to run a game for them isn’t even close to choosing a time, place or game.





