Artizan vs. Crusader Review
While I wait for my latest order of figures to arrive I think it would be a good time to review the two manufacturers I have used so far. In the beginning I had written a series of posts where I looked at the different miniatures available and decided which I would use for my project. Now that’s I’ve painted miniatures from the two manufacturers I chose it is a good time to compare and contrast them.

Crusader Miniatures, WWB102: Late British Riflemen II.
I’ll leave my favorite for last, otherwise I may use up all my good energy describing it and leave only vitriol and hate for my second-favorite. I only purchased one pack of Crusader miniatures and will likely only purchase more if my force grows so large that I want to introduce some variety, or if my preferred manufacturer doesn’t make a specific model I need.
It’s important, before I start criticizing, that I make it clear that I would use these miniatures. They are serviceable, but I prefer Artizan.
I found the Crusader miniatures to be chunkier, especially in the size of the rifle and hands. In some ways the rifle has better detail, despite it’s stubby-ness. Unfortunately for an inexplicable reason the sculptor chose to render the weapon with a rectangular cross-section.
Folds in clothing are both softer and muddier. I am not being redundant when I say this, soft folds in clothing helps to give the clothing weight. I don’t think this is appropriate for WWII British Battledress, but not automatically a negative. Sculpting is muddy when details are either unclear or confusing, such as in the front of miniatures left lower leg–your right. I’m not sure what the sculptor was intending but the result is a weirdly lumpy mess.
One area where Crusader outperforms Artizan is the addition of the rolled blanket under the haversack’s flap. It was nice to see some variation.
I’m not an expert on WWII British uniforms but accuracy looks good to my eyes. I try not to be too picky as I’m painting WWII Canadians who’s uniforms and equipment differed slightly from the British. I do think that the sculptor is probably not an expert either, a situation I think is more common than not.
Overall I’d say Crusader is a good miniature for the money. Strange details like rifles with a square cross-section are questionable, but this isn’t apparent from the tabletop. I purchased these miniatures at $9 CAD for four, or $2.25 per figure.

Artizan Miniatures, from various packs of WWII British Riflemen.
Artizan was my clear favorite. Detail was finer, with slimmer figures and rifles. Artizan also seems to show—I’ve only painted four Crusader miniatures, mind—more animation in pose and facial expression. There is a strange inconsistency in the webbing, whether it passes through the shoulder flaps or not. I also sometimes wonder what happened during casting, as a few miniatures have helmets that don’t line up well with the head, and one poor soldier’s haversack is hanging off his soldier like how the cool kids in elementary school wore their book bags. Even worse, there’s an inexplicable raised, round blank. My guess for the helmets is that they were sculpted and cast, then added to the finished heads, as were the haversacks. These must has slipped when the master mold was being created.
Artizan suffers the same feeling that the sculptor is not an expert in the subject as Crusader. I don’t think it pays to be a button-counter in this hobby. Next time someone points out that for two months in 1942 German soldiers were issued with new boots and ordered to keep them shined to a high gloss, thus your choice of matte varnish on the boots is incorrect quickly look around. I will wager dollars to donuts that said fellow hasn’t brought any miniatures of his own.
I really wish, however, that Artizan had payed a bit more attention to sculpting some believable detail into the rifles. Otherwise, I really like these miniatures and how they’ve painted up. I plan to expand my collection with more miniatures from Artizan, but not right away. I purchased the miniatures for $11 CAD for four, or $2.75 a figure. I think that this miniatures are well worth $.50 more a miniature than Crusader.
I hope this review has been useful for another looking for a manufacturer of miniatures. One question I anticipate is how well the two lines mix. Knowing the differences between the two I can pick out the four Crusader miniatures from my collection. On the table the will be nearly indistinguishable. In the first picture you can see an Artizan figure in the background.
Tyler



